Markets
Markets & Economy

Private Credit's Record Default Count Is Being Buried by Its Own Averages

Direct lending's medians still look calm. A record 112 defaults in KBRA's monitor, 362 non-accrual borrowers in BDC filings and $107 billion maturing in 2027 show where the damage actually sits.

Loan documents stacked on a boardroom table in low light, representing private credit surveillance and rising borrower defaults

Private credit's headline numbers and its underlying reality are pointing in opposite directions. The median borrower still looks healthy while the count of defaults sits at a record, surveillance downgrades pile up and non-accrual lists swell. The gap between the average and the tail is the story, and the way the asset class measures itself hides it.

KBRA's latest middle-market review is the most complete picture. Its compendium covers 3,070 middle-market borrowers representing more than $1.4 trillion of direct lending debt assessed in the twelve months to 30 September 2026. The default count is the eye-catcher: the Middle Market Default Monitor reached a record 112 borrowers, the largest quarterly gain in the series, with the rate by count rising to about 3.6%. That is the highest level in 2026, though below the early-2025 peak of 3.9%.

Where those defaults cluster matters as much as the count. Commercial and Professional Services and Health Care Services and Technology accounted for 16 of the 35 additions in the third quarter, with twelve-month default rates by count of 4.6% and 4.4%. KBRA describes lower middle-market borrowers as increasingly vulnerable to operating, liquidity and leverage pressures.

The median barely moved. Revenue growth was unchanged at 12%, EBITDA growth slowed to 23%, and median leverage reached 6.2x, its first increase in more than two years. Interest coverage held at 1.6x. On those figures alone, the asset class looks steady. The tail says otherwise: about 20% of borrowers reported negative revenue growth, the highest share in the series and roughly twice the level at the start of 2024, and more than half of those also reported lower EBITDA. Surveillance downgrades reached a record 121, lifting the rate to 15% from 11% the prior quarter, while the share of new assessments rated ccc+ or lower rose to a record 31% from 19%.

BDC filings converge on the same picture from a different angle. An analysis of more than ten years of quarterly filings from all US-based, SEC-registered BDCs, covering 245 distinct vehicles holding $563 billion at cost as of June, put non-accrual borrowers at a record 362 in the second quarter, up from 291 a year earlier and about 35% above the pandemic-era peak. Non-accrual debt was $9.7 billion, down 7% from the first quarter's record but up 64% year over year, or 1.9% of total BDC debt at cost. Medallia alone accounted for about $1.9 billion of that, roughly 20% of the total, so the rate would be 1.5% without it.

That figure looks serene next to the borrower count, and the reconciliation is where the disclosure question lives. BDCs can mark troubled positions down to fair value while keeping them on accrual, so stress surfaces through payment-in-kind income and deeper markdowns rather than in headline non-accrual rates. Privately negotiated amendments, distressed exchanges, maturity extensions and liability management exercises became far more common after the pandemic, and are typically struck bilaterally or with a small lender group, which makes them hard to track. Exposure to non-accrual-affected borrowers, counting still-performing debt of the same names, reached $18.8 billion, up 95% from a year earlier, or 3.6% of total BDC debt against 2.1%.

The third dataset covers the plumbing that keeps investors from seeing any of this. ASIC's report on Australian private credit funds examined 24 funds holding about A$18 billion between November 2025 and August 2026, in a market estimated at more than A$250 billion. Eighteen of the 24 used several layers of intermediary entities, including special purpose vehicles and warehouse vehicles, some without clear disclosure. Only two of the 22 retail and wholesale funds reviewed passed the full economic benefits of interest and borrower fees to investors. Seven of 10 retail funds and nine of 12 wholesale funds retained establishment or origination fees, two without disclosing the practice. In one case, undisclosed borrower fees, interest margin and default interest retained by a related-party lender exceeded four times the disclosed management costs, and for every $1 distributed to investors the related party received 38 cents. Nine of 12 retail funds did not clearly disclose key information for an investment decision. ASIC issued six interim stop orders and made poor practices in private credit a 2026-27 enforcement priority.

The forcing event is on the calendar. KBRA counts 115 companies with $26.9 billion maturing for the rest of 2026, but in 2027 maturities jump to 350 companies with $107 billion due. Health Care Services and Technology faces the largest wall, about $36 billion in 2027, of which $8 billion is owed by companies rated ccc+ or ccc. KBRA notes that a modest rate increase would likely have a limited impact on most borrowers, while highly leveraged credits with limited liquidity remain vulnerable.

None of the three datasets proves a crisis. What they establish is that the instruments investors rely on, headline default rates, non-accrual percentages and fund disclosures, are structurally incapable of showing where the damage sits. The averages will keep looking acceptable while the tail deteriorates, and the mechanism that would settle the question is the one already scheduled: maturing debt meeting a market that has to price it.